All four clarinets compared here are assessed on documented specifications and market positioning, not hands-on playing tests. Body material (ABS resin vs. ebonite) is the main construction difference worth understanding before choosing between these options.
Who this guide is for
Parents and beginner players choosing a first Bb clarinet for school band programs or private lessons.
Our selection methodology
Every product above is assessed from manufacturer specification pages and named retailer listings, cross-checked across at least two sources where possible — not from hands-on play-testing. Each product's own Review Basis field and this guide's comparison both say so explicitly, per the site's interim trust policy on review badges.
Yamaha's newly redesigned ABS-resin body is documented as more resistant to cracking from humidity/temperature swings than a wood student clarinet, from a brand with wide retailer and repair-shop availability.
A full Boehm 17-key system and adjustable thumb rest at a price point below Yamaha's, from a brand selling primarily through direct online channels to keep costs down.
The most complete included accessory bundle among the four compared (10 reeds, folding stand, practice book, two replaceable barrels) at the lowest typical price point.
A 0.577" cylindrical bore the manufacturer specifically describes as easy for students to blow, from a brand already featured on this site for trumpet.
Prelude is Conn-Selmer's dedicated entry-level line, with a hard-rubber body the manufacturer describes as mimicking a wood clarinet's tone, and a documented .583" bore for a fuller sound.
Yamaha's newly redesigned ABS-resin body is documented as more resistant to cracking from humidity/temperature swings than a wood student clarinet, from a brand with wide retailer and repair-shop availability.
Suitable for
Beginner-through-early-student players wanting broad brand and repair-shop familiarity.
Not ideal for
Players who specifically want a wood-body clarinet from the outset.
What distinguishes it
ABS resin body with temperature-stable Valentino pads, per Yamaha's own product materials.
Compromises
Priced above the Jean Paul USA, Mendini, and Allora options compared here.
Verify before buying
Confirm current price and stock at the time of purchase.
Alternative: Jean Paul USA CL-300, for a similar 17-key Boehm system at a lower price point.
Jean Paul USA CL-300 Student Clarinet — Best value with full key system
A full Boehm 17-key system and adjustable thumb rest at a price point below Yamaha's, from a brand selling primarily through direct online channels to keep costs down.
Suitable for
Budget-conscious families wanting the standard key system without Yamaha's price premium.
Not ideal for
Buyers who specifically want a longer-established brand with a deeper repair-shop network.
What distinguishes it
Full Boehm 17-key system at a below-Yamaha price point.
Compromises
No hands-on or independent third-party expert assessment was located for this specific model in this research pass.
Verify before buying
Confirm current stock — Jean Paul USA listings sometimes rotate between near-identical ASINs.
Alternative: Mendini by Cecilio Bb Clarinet, for an even lower typical price point with a fuller accessory bundle.
The most complete included accessory bundle among the four compared (10 reeds, folding stand, practice book, two replaceable barrels) at the lowest typical price point.
Suitable for
Budget-conscious families testing commitment before a bigger purchase.
Not ideal for
Players who already know they will stay on clarinet long-term and want an instrument with a longer established resale/service history.
What distinguishes it
Fullest included accessory kit of the four products compared.
Compromises
No hands-on or independent third-party expert assessment was located for this specific model in this research pass.
Verify before buying
Confirm the exact bundle variant directly with the seller before buying.
Alternative: Jean Paul USA CL-300, for a similar price tier with a slightly different key-system presentation.
Allora Student Series Bb Clarinet AACL-336 — Best documented bore for beginner ease-of-play
A 0.577" cylindrical bore the manufacturer specifically describes as easy for students to blow, from a brand already featured on this site for trumpet.
Suitable for
Beginners prioritizing ease of initial sound production.
Not ideal for
Buyers who specifically want the widest brand recognition.
What distinguishes it
Documented 0.577" bore specification aimed at beginner ease-of-play.
Compromises
No hands-on or independent third-party expert assessment was located for this specific model in this research pass.
Verify before buying
Confirm current price and stock directly with the retailer.
Alternative: Yamaha YCL-255, for a documented ABS-resin construction upgrade.
Prelude CL711 Bb Student Clarinet — Best from a major brand's budget line
Prelude is Conn-Selmer's dedicated entry-level line, with a hard-rubber body the manufacturer describes as mimicking a wood clarinet's tone, and a documented .583" bore for a fuller sound.
Suitable for
Families wanting the backing of a large, established manufacturer's dedicated beginner line.
Not ideal for
Buyers on the tightest possible budget.
What distinguishes it
Backed by Conn-Selmer rather than a smaller specialist or budget-import brand; documented wide bore for tone.
Compromises
Prices seen in this research pass varied widely by retailer (roughly $199-$479) — confirm current price before buying.
Verify before buying
Confirm current price directly with the retailer given the wide range seen across sources.
Alternative: Yamaha YCL-255, for a comparable established-manufacturer track record.
Common buying mistakes
!Choosing based on body material alone without checking key-system completeness (all four compared here use the standard Boehm 17-key system, so this isn't actually a differentiator among them).
!Skipping a professional setup/adjustment check on a low-cost import clarinet before the return window closes.
!Assuming a wood-body clarinet is automatically "better" — ABS resin avoids a wood clarinet's real crack risk in dry or fluctuating climates.
Frequently asked questions
Not for a beginner. ABS resin avoids the crack risk that affects wood (grenadilla) clarinets in dry or fluctuating humidity, and is standard on nearly every entry-level student clarinet, including Yamaha’s.
The Boehm 17-key system is the standard used across all four clarinets compared in this guide, and is what most school band programs teach on.
Update log
2026-08-02Initial publication — promotes Clarinet from a Flute-comparison-only instrument to a fully product-covered instrument.
This guide contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission — this never affects which products we recommend or how we rank them. See our Affiliate Disclosure.
We use cookies to make this site work and, if you allow it, to understand how it's used and improve it. You choose which categories are on. Read more in our cookie policy.
Choose which categories of cookies we're allowed to use. You can change this again at any time from "Cookie settings" in the footer.
Necessary
Always on — required for the site to function.
Analytics
Helps us understand how the site is used (Google Analytics) so we can improve it. No data is used to identify you personally.
